Automotive quality

VDA 6.3 vs IATF 16949: what is different and what maintenance must show for each

IATF 16949 is the quality management system standard your plant is certified to. VDA 6.3 is a process audit method that scores, question by question, whether a process actually works on the floor. For maintenance, IATF asks you to prove the system exists and runs, and VDA 6.3 asks you to prove it works on the specific machines that make the audited part. The same records can answer both, if they are tied to the machine.

By Mauli Patel, Client Success Architect, CodiotPublished Last reviewed 8 min read

VDA 6.3 and IATF 16949 look at the same machine records through two different lenses A pencil sketch. At the bottom, one press with its maintenance record: PM, spares, breakdowns and gauges. An arrow goes up left to a certificate labelled IATF 16949, asking whether the system is in place, with the result certified or a nonconformity. An arrow goes up right to a score sheet labelled VDA 6.3, asking whether the process works on the floor, with each question scored 10, 8, 6, 4 or 0 and a result of A, B or C. IATF 16949 IS THE SYSTEM THERE? CERTIFIED, OR A NONCONFORMITY VDA 6.3 DOES THE PROCESS WORK? 10 8 6 4 0 PER QUESTION RESULT: A, B OR C PM, SPARES, BREAKDOWNS, GAUGES One press, one record
Both audits end up at the same machine. IATF 16949 checks that the maintenance system is there and running. VDA 6.3 scores whether it works for the process in front of the auditor.

The short version: a system standard and a process audit

If you supply the automotive industry from India, you probably meet both. Your IATF 16949 certificate is often the entry ticket to a customer's supplier list. Then a VDA 6.3 audit arrives, usually from a customer's supplier quality team, sometimes before a new part is awarded, sometimes after a quality problem. Many plants also use VDA 6.3 for their own internal process audits.

IATF 16949 was published by the International Automotive Task Force in 2016. It is used together with ISO 9001 and sets requirements for the whole quality management system. A certification body recognised under the IATF rules audits your site, and the result is a certificate or a list of nonconformities, graded major or minor. Surveillance audits follow through the certificate cycle.

VDA 6.3 is published by VDA QMC, the quality management centre of the German Association of the Automotive Industry. According to VDA QMC, the current edition was published in January 2023. It is a questionnaire for auditing a process. P1 is a potential analysis for new suppliers. A full process audit covers P2 to P7, from project management through development, supplier management and production to customer care. Each question is scored 10, 8, 6, 4 or 0, some questions are marked with a star, and the result is classified A, B or C.

The two meet in one place. IATF 16949 asks you to audit every manufacturing process over a three-year cycle and to use the customer's required approach for those audits. When your customer requires VDA 6.3, your internal process audits follow it too.

VDA 6.3 vs IATF 16949 side by side

Use this to explain the difference to a new maintenance engineer or a plant head who has only seen one of the two. It is a summary, not the text of either document. Read the licensed standard and the VDA volume for the exact wording.

VDA 6.3 and IATF 16949 compared
IATF 16949VDA 6.3
What it isA quality management system standardA process audit method with a fixed question set
Who audits youA certification body recognised under the IATF rulesUsually your customer, or your own qualified internal auditors
What is judgedWhether the system meets each clauseWhether one process, for one product, works and is controlled
ResultCertificate, or major and minor nonconformitiesA score per question and an A, B or C classification
Auditor qualificationThird-party IATF auditorVDA 6.3 process auditor qualification for internal and external auditors
Where maintenance shows up mostTotal productive maintenance, tooling, measurement resourcesProduction (P6), in the questions on material resources: equipment, tools, maintenance and test equipment
How the auditor worksSamples records across the systemWalks the process, station by station, and asks to see it working

A plant can hold a clean IATF 16949 certificate and still score poorly in a VDA 6.3 audit. The certificate says the system exists. The process audit tests one process in depth.

What maintenance must show for each

Most of the evidence is the same. The difference is the question behind it. Copy this into your audit preparation sheet and fill the last column with where each record lives in your plant.

Maintenance evidence for IATF 16949 and VDA 6.3
EvidenceIATF 16949 asksVDA 6.3 asksWhere it lives (fill in)
Equipment list with criticalityHave you identified the equipment needed to make conforming product?Is the equipment for this process step capable and under control?
PM plan and on-time completionIs preventive maintenance planned, resourced and done?Was PM done on this machine, and can you show the last closed jobs?
Critical sparesAre replacement parts available for key equipment?If this machine fails tonight, how long until it runs again?
Maintenance objectivesDo you set objectives such as OEE, MTBF, MTTR or PM compliance, review them and act when missed?Are failures on this process analysed and acted on?
Breakdown to corrective actionIs there a documented action plan when an objective is missed?Is the repeat failure closed with a cause and a check that the fix worked?
Tooling and diesIs there a tooling management system?Are tools maintained, stored and released before use?
Gauges and calibrationAre measuring resources calibrated and traceable?Can the gauge at this station check this characteristic, and is it in date?

If your MTBF and MTTR objectives come from a spreadsheet nobody can trace, rebuild them from logged breakdowns first. The MTBF and MTTR calculator shows the arithmetic.

Worked example: one press, two audits

Worked example (illustrative)

Take a sheet metal stamping supplier in Oragadam, near Chennai. It is IATF 16949 certified and makes brackets for a Tier 1 that supplies a German carmaker. The key machine is a 400 tonne mechanical press. All numbers and findings below are illustrative.

The IATF surveillance audit. The auditor samples maintenance objectives. The plant has set an MTBF objective of 120 hours for the press line. For two months in a row the line ran at about 96 hours. The monthly review minutes mention the miss, but there is no action plan with an owner and a date. The auditor raises a minor nonconformity against the requirement to act when objectives are not met. Everything else in maintenance is sampled and accepted.

The VDA 6.3 audit, three months later. The customer's auditor audits the bracket process and stands at the press. The maintenance-related part of the walk is scored like this:

Topic at the pressWhat the auditor sawScore (illustrative)
PM plan and completionPlan in place, last six PMs closed on time with readings8
Die maintenanceDie cleaned after every run, but no stroke count to trigger regrinding6
Critical sparesClutch and brake spares not named, lead time unknown4
Repeat breakdownSame hydraulic overload trip on three work orders, no root cause recorded4
Gauge at the stationHeight gauge in date, certificate traceable10
Total for this slice32 of 50 possible points64%

What the example shows (illustrative). The same press passed the IATF audit with one minor finding, then lost most of its points in VDA 6.3 on two topics: spares and a repeat failure. Neither was hidden. They were simply not tied to the machine. A real VDA 6.3 result is calculated across all questions and elements, with special rules for starred questions, so do not read this slice as a rating. The fixes are small: name the clutch and brake spares with stock and lead time, run a root cause on the overload trip and link it to the three work orders, and add a stroke count trigger for the die.

One set of records for both audits

Five records that answer both audits Five records tick in turn: asset list by criticality, PM plan done on time, critical spares named, breakdowns closed with a cause, and gauges in date with certificates. Then a line draws to two labels: IATF 16949 and VDA 6.3, both served by the same records. Asset list by criticality PM plan, done on time Critical spares named Breakdowns closed with a cause Gauges in date, certificates IATF16949 VDA 6.3
Five records, kept against each machine, answer most of what both auditors ask of maintenance.
  1. Start from the customer's parts. List the machines that make the parts in the scope of your next VDA 6.3 audit. Mark them by criticality.
  2. Open each machine and time yourself. Try to show the PM plan, the last three closed PMs, the critical spares, the last breakdown and the gauges used at that station. Anything that takes more than a few minutes is a gap.
  3. Close the loop on repeat failures. For every breakdown that happened twice, write the cause and the action on the work order, and check whether it came back.
  4. Write the action where the objective lives. When an MTBF, MTTR or PM compliance objective is missed, record the action, owner and date next to it. This is what the IATF auditor samples.
  5. Run an internal VDA 6.3 walk. Use a qualified internal auditor and the current question set on one process. Score it honestly, then fix the lowest scores first. The VDA 6.3 maintenance audit checklist helps you prepare.

You do not need two systems. You need one record per machine that a quality engineer and an auditor can both open. Use this order to get there:

Common mistakes

  • Treating the IATF certificate as proof for VDA 6.3. The certificate says your system exists. A VDA 6.3 auditor wants to see this machine, this die and this gauge working today.
  • Preparing documents instead of the floor. A VDA 6.3 auditor walks the process. A neat procedure in the quality office does not help if the operator cannot show the PM record at the press.
  • Objectives with no action. Setting MTBF or OEE targets and then not acting when they are missed is one of the easiest findings to avoid.
  • Repairs logged without a cause. Three work orders for the same trip, each closed as "reset and run", tell the auditor that failures are not analysed.
  • Forgetting tools and dies. Maintenance often owns the press but not the die. In a stamping or casting plant, die records are part of the same question.
  • Using an old question set. VDA QMC published the current VDA 6.3 edition in January 2023. Internal audits based on an older checklist may miss questions your customer will ask.

Sources

  1. VDA 6.3 FAQ (opens in a new tab), VDA QMC (Quality Management Center of the German Association of the Automotive Industry)
  2. IATF global oversight (opens in a new tab), International Automotive Task Force
  3. About IATF (opens in a new tab), International Automotive Task Force

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between VDA 6.3 and IATF 16949?

IATF 16949 is a quality management system standard that your site is certified to by a certification body. VDA 6.3 is a process audit method, often used by customers, that scores whether a specific process works on the floor.

Do I need VDA 6.3 if I am IATF 16949 certified?

Often, yes. Many customers ask for VDA 6.3 audits of their suppliers, and IATF 16949 asks you to use the customer's required approach for your own manufacturing process audits.

How is a VDA 6.3 audit scored?

Each question is scored 10, 8, 6, 4 or 0. Some questions are marked with a star. The results are combined and the process is classified A, B or C, using the rules in the current VDA 6.3 volume.

Where does maintenance appear in VDA 6.3?

Mostly in the production element, P6, in the questions on material resources such as equipment, tools, maintenance and test equipment. Failure analysis and corrective action also come up across the audit.

Which IATF 16949 clause covers maintenance?

The main one is the total productive maintenance requirement, often cited as clause 8.5.1.5 of IATF 16949:2016. Tooling management and measurement resources also apply to maintenance work.

Fix it before it fails.

Start a free trial today, or book a demo tailored to your plant, assets and standards.

Start with one line. Extend when it works.