Performance

What is a good OEE score? Benchmarks and the six big losses

The OEE figure most often quoted as the benchmark is 85%, from Seiichi Nakajima's TPM work in Japan, but many plants measure much lower when they first count honestly. A good OEE score is one that rises steadily on the same machine, under the same counting rules. To move it, find which of the six big losses takes the most minutes and work on that first.

By Urvish Savalia, Co-founder, Codiot TechnologiesPublished Last reviewed 7 min read

A good OEE score depends on where the losses sit A pencil sketch. On the left, a gauge from 0 to 100 percent with marks at 40, 60 and 85, and a needle pointing near 67. A legend reads 40 starting out, 60 typical, 85 Nakajima's benchmark. On the right, a bar for planned production time shrinks three times: availability loss from breakdowns and setups, performance loss from small stops and slow cycles, and quality loss from startup and process rejects. What is left is good parts at full speed, which is OEE. 406085 40 STARTING OUT 60 TYPICAL 85 NAKAJIMA'S BENCHMARK PLANNED PRODUCTION TIME AVAILABILITY: BREAKDOWNS, SETUPS PERFORMANCE: SMALL STOPS, SLOW CYCLES QUALITY: STARTUP, PROCESS REJECTS Good parts at full speed: this is OEE Read the losses, not just the score
The score on the gauge only tells you how far you are from full output. The bar tells you where the time went.

Where the 85% OEE benchmark comes from

OEE (overall equipment effectiveness) is the share of planned production time that made good parts at full speed. It multiplies three factors: Availability, Performance and Quality. If you need the formula or want to work out your own number, use the free OEE calculator first and come back.

The 85% figure goes back to Seiichi Nakajima, who led the work on TPM, OEE and the six big losses at the Japan Institute of Plant Maintenance. In Introduction to TPM (1984 in Japanese, 1988 in English) he gave minimum goals for each factor. They are usually quoted as:

  • Availability: 90%
  • Performance: 95%
  • Quality: 99.9%
  • OEE: about 85% (0.90 × 0.95 × 0.999)

Notice how uneven the factor goals are. Quality is almost perfect, Availability has the most room. That is because a reject is expensive in a way that a short stop is not.

Also notice where the numbers come from. Vorne Industries, which publishes OEE.com, points out that they were set in Japan, in the 1970s, mostly for automotive plants, and apply to discrete manufacturing rather than process plants. Vorne also writes that most manufacturers it works with sit closer to 60%. So 85% is a good long-term direction. It is a poor first target for a plant that has just started measuring.

OEE benchmarks: a rough guide you can copy

Use these bands to decide where to look first, not to grade your team. They are rules of thumb drawn from the sources below, not an industry standard, and the same score means different things on a single-product press and a high-mix CNC cell.

Rough OEE bands and the first thing to check
Your OEEWhat it usually saysCheck first
Below 40%Common when a plant first measures honestly, or when the rules are too strictAre planned breaks and planned PM taken out of planned time? Is the ideal cycle time realistic?
40% to 60%Large, visible losses. Plenty to gain from basicsThe two biggest losses by minutes. Usually breakdowns or changeovers
60% to 75%Basics are in place. Hidden losses start to matterMinor stops and slow cycles that nobody logs
75% to 85%A well-run line by most yardsticksStartup rejects, speed losses on specific products, setup time
Above 85%Either very good, or the rules are too generousAudit the inputs before you celebrate: ideal cycle time, what counts as planned time

Whatever band you are in, compare a machine with itself over time. A jump of ten points after a change of counting rules is not improvement.

The six big losses, and how to log each one

Nakajima grouped equipment losses into six and tied each pair to one OEE factor. Knowing the score without knowing the losses is like knowing your temperature without knowing why. The TPM guide covers the background. This table is about capture: how each loss gets into your records on a normal shift, and who usually acts on it.

The six big losses: factor, how to capture and usual owner
LossOEE factorHow to capture itUsual owner
Equipment failureAvailabilityBreakdown logged against the machine with start time, end time and causeMaintenance
Setup and adjustmentAvailabilityChangeover start to first good part, per product changeProduction and setup crew
Idling and minor stopsPerformanceShort stops tallied by the operator, or counted from sensor signalsProduction with maintenance
Reduced speedPerformanceActual count against ideal cycle time. Any gap not explained by stopsProcess engineering
Startup rejectsQualityRejects from warm-up and the first parts after a start or changeoverProduction and quality
Process defectsQualityScrap and rework during steady running, by defect typeQuality

Minor stops and reduced speed are the two that most plants never log. They hide inside Performance, and they are often bigger than the breakdowns everyone talks about.

Worked example: a CNC turning cell in Chakan

Worked example (illustrative)

Take a CNC turning cell at an auto component supplier near Chakan, Pune. It runs two shifts of 480 minutes, six days a week, with a 30 minute meal break per shift. Planned production time for the week is 6 × 2 × 450 = 5,400 minutes. The cell makes ten variants of a shaft, so it changes over often. The plant head has put an 85% OEE target on the wall because it appeared on a slide. All numbers below are illustrative.

In the week the team logs 310 minutes of breakdowns and 16 changeovers of about 40 minutes each, 640 minutes in total. The ideal cycle time is 1.5 minutes per part. The cell makes 2,500 parts, and 2,410 are good. The operators keep a tally of short stops, which adds up to about 380 minutes.

ItemCalculationResult
Run time5,400 - 310 - 6404,450 min
Availability4,450 ÷ 5,40082.4%
Performance(1.5 × 2,500) ÷ 4,450 = 3,750 ÷ 4,45084.3%
Quality2,410 ÷ 2,50096.4%
OEE0.824 × 0.843 × 0.96466.9%
Setup and adjustment16 changeovers640 min
Minor stopsOperator tally380 min
Reduced speed4,450 - 3,750 - 380320 min
Equipment failureLogged breakdowns310 min
Startup rejects55 parts × 1.582.5 min
Process defects35 parts × 1.552.5 min

What the example shows (illustrative). The six losses add up to 1,785 minutes, and 2,410 good parts × 1.5 minutes is 3,615 fully productive minutes. Together they make the 5,400 planned. OEE is 66.9%, which sounds bad against 85%. But the biggest loss is not breakdowns, it is changeovers. If setup work brings each changeover from 40 to 25 minutes, the cell gets back 240 minutes. At the same speed and quality that is about 240 × 0.843 × 0.964 ≈ 195 productive minutes, or 3.6 points of OEE. A believable three month target is about 70%, with changeover time as the measure the team watches every day.

How to set an OEE target your team will believe

One week of losses on an illustrative CNC cell, ranked by minutes Six bars draw in turn, longest first: setup and adjustment 640 minutes, minor stops 380, reduced speed 320, equipment failure 310, startup rejects 82.5 and process defects 52.5. All numbers are illustrative. Setup and adjustment640 Minor stops380 Reduced speed320 Equipment failure310 Startup rejects82.5 Process defects52.5
The same illustrative week, ranked by minutes. The longest bar is where the next three months of effort should go.
  1. Fix the counting rules first. Write down what is planned time, what is a stop, what ideal cycle time you use and what counts as a good part. Use the same rules on every line.
  2. Measure for four weeks before you set anything. One good week proves nothing. You want a baseline you trust.
  3. Rank the six losses by minutes, not by how loud the complaints are. Minutes turn into OEE points directly. Percentages hide the size.
  4. Pick one or two losses and set a target on them. Changeover minutes, breakdown minutes or minor stops per shift. People can act on these.
  5. Set the OEE target as the result. Work out what the loss target is worth in points, as in the example, and aim for that within three or four months.
  6. Review weekly, reset quarterly. When the target loss is under control, move to the next longest bar.

A target works when the people on the line think they can hit it and can see what to change. An 85% sign on the wall does neither. Use this sequence instead:

Common mistakes

  • Copying 85% onto every line. A line that makes one product all day and a cell that changes over sixteen times a week will never have the same OEE. Set targets per line, from that line's own baseline.
  • Comparing plants with different rules. One plant takes planned maintenance out of planned time, another counts it as downtime. Their scores are not comparable until the rules match.
  • Setting the ideal cycle time from today's average. If the ideal is too slow, Performance looks fine and reduced speed disappears. Use the design rate or the best proven rate.
  • Averaging OEE percentages across machines. Add the minutes and counts first, then calculate the plant figure.
  • Logging only breakdowns. Then Availability is the only loss anyone sees, and maintenance gets blamed for a score that minor stops and changeovers are pulling down.
  • Treating OEE as a maintenance score. Maintenance owns a large share of Availability, but setups, speed and rejects belong to production, process and quality too. The OEE guide for maintenance leaders shows which part is maintenance's to fix.

Sources

  1. World class OEE (opens in a new tab), OEE.com (Vorne Industries)
  2. Six big losses (opens in a new tab), OEE.com (Vorne Industries)
  3. What is TPM? (opens in a new tab), Japan Institute of Plant Maintenance (JIPM)
  4. Overall equipment effectiveness (opens in a new tab), Wikipedia

Frequently asked questions

What is a good OEE score?

The benchmark most often quoted is 85%, from Seiichi Nakajima's TPM work. Many plants measure well below that when they first count honestly. A good score is one that rises steadily on the same machine under the same counting rules.

Is 85% OEE realistic for an Indian plant?

It can be, on a stable line with few changeovers and good basics. For most plants it is a long-term direction. Set a first target from your own four-week baseline and the biggest loss you plan to cut.

What are the six big losses in OEE?

Equipment failure and setup and adjustment reduce Availability. Idling and minor stops and reduced speed reduce Performance. Startup rejects and process defects reduce Quality.

Why is my OEE so much lower than my availability?

OEE multiplies Availability, Performance and Quality, so the losses stack. A line at 90% on all three factors has an OEE of about 73%.

Should every line have the same OEE target?

No. A high-mix line loses more time to changeovers than a single-product line. Set each target from that line's own baseline and compare a line with itself over time.

Fix it before it fails.

Start a free trial today, or book a demo tailored to your plant, assets and standards.

Start with one line. Extend when it works.